ForestryBrief Professional #5 🌳💰

Last week, I showed you where 80% of your carbon credit money disappears.

This week, I'll show you who has the other 20%. And more importantly, who wants to buy it.

Because here's what nobody tells you: European carbon credits command massive premiums over tropical credits. Same CO2. Same climate impact. Completely different prices.

Want to know why? Let me show you what's really happening.

(Note: The following scenario illustrates typical market dynamics based on industry patterns)

Picture a German manufacturer buying carbon credits. They have two options:

Option A: Brazilian forest credits at $8-12 per tonne (industry average) Option B: European forest credits at $20-70 per tonne (verified range)

They choose Option B. Every time.

Why pay 3-4 times more for the same tonne of CO2? Seven reasons that nobody discusses openly:

Reason 1: Regulatory Acceptance The EU Taxonomy exists. CSRD compliance is mandatory. European credits face less regulatory scrutiny.

Reason 2: Transport Emissions Buying Brazilian credits adds transport emissions to Scope 3 reporting. European credits don't.

Reason 3: Legal Certainty EU property rights are clear. Forest ownership is documented. Reversal risk is lower.

Reason 4: Supply Scarcity This one's verified: Europe produced just 65,041 forest credits in 2024. Global production: 13.4 million. We have 0.5% of supply.

Reason 5: Co-Benefits European projects often track biodiversity and water impacts. Buyers value these extras.

Reason 6: Verification Standards European monitoring is stricter. More expensive, yes. But buyers trust it more.

Reason 7: Proximity Preference Companies prefer local projects. It's not always logical. But it's real.

Here's verified data that should alarm every European sustainability manager:

Now add this:

The math doesn't work. There aren't enough European credits. Not even close.

Three regulations are about to transform this market. Most forest owners don't know they're coming.

The Carbon Removal Certification Framework entered force December 26, 2024. Here's what it means:

Start preparing now. When this launches, demand will spike.

The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive forces transparency:

Who must comply:

What they report:

Translation: 50,000 companies suddenly need quality credits. Europe has 65,041 to offer.

Want to see why YOUR forest commands premium prices? Our free calculator shows your premium factors. Calculate your 7 premium factors and estimated price range Now let's look at the third regulation...

Starting 2027, airlines face mandatory offsetting:

Airlines will compete for quality credits. European forests qualify.

You now understand why European forest credits command 400% premiums. You know 50,000 companies need credits that don't exist. You see the regulatory tsunami approaching. But knowing the opportunity means nothing without knowing the players.

Not all European markets are equal. Here's what we can verify:

Germany's national carbon price hit €55 per tonne in 2025 (up from €45 in 2024).

Verified facts:

German companies understand carbon pricing. They're prepared to pay.

The Woodland Carbon Code shows verified pricing:

Price evolution:

The UK publishes all prices. No hidden markups. Clear market signals.

France's program has certified 600+ forest projects.

What we know:

Specific pricing varies by project and buyer.

Nordic countries show increasing interest, but verified data is limited. Watch this space.

Here's what we can confirm about major buyers:

Microsoft - Verified Data:

Microsoft pays premium prices for premium projects.

Shell - Verified Data:

Shell announced scaling back nature-based solutions. Watch for market shifts.

European manufacturers increasingly buy regional credits, but specific data remains confidential. Industry reports suggest 25-40% premiums for local projects.

Beyond carbon, new markets are emerging:

Verified developments:

Pilots are testing credits in the €20-50 range. Not verified sales yet - just pilots.

Water credits remain conceptual in Europe. Some pilots exist, but no established market yet.

Here's a theoretical projection for a 100-hectare forest by 2030:

*These are projections based on pilot programs, not guaranteed outcomes.

Stop guessing at Natural Capital revenues. Build your specific projection. Project your carbon + biodiversity + water revenue streams through 2030. After understanding revenue potential, let's examine certification costs...

Verified certification costs are hard to find. Based on industry reports:

National programs generally cost less than international standards.

Which country offers YOUR best opportunity? Take this 2-minute assessment. Now let's match strategies to forest size...

The below strategies are based on market analysis:

Going solo rarely works. You have 3 options:

Expected returns vary widely by approach.

You have more options:

Success depends on management quality.

Direct certification becomes feasible:

Large forests have negotiating power.

But which buyers actually want YOUR specific forest? Stop guessing. Our Buyer Compatibility Matrix analyzes your forest against 45 active purchasers. See your match scores with Microsoft, Shell, BMW, and 42 others. With your buyers identified, let's examine market indicators...

What we know for certain:

Supply Side:

Demand Side:

Price Signals:

Based on verified regulatory timelines we can expect:

2025-2026:

2027-2029:

2030+:

The data shows clear opportunity. Here's how to position:

Week 1: Assessment

Week 2: Market Research

Week 3: Options Analysis

Week 4: Decision

Focus on fundamentals:

Truth 1: Small forests face severe economic challenges in carbon markets. Cooperation is essential.

Truth 2: Most aggregators take 30-60% of revenue. This is documented fact.

Truth 3: The opportunity window is real but closing. Early movers capture premium positions.

The data is clear:

The question isn't whether European credits command premiums. They do.

The question is whether you can access this market profitably. That depends on your size, location, and strategy.

Timing is everything. Our CSRD Timeline Tool shows exactly when to enter. See when 50,000 buyers need YOUR credits and optimize entry timing. Now you know when to move. Next week, I'll show you how...

Part 4 reveals implementation details:

The complete roadmap from forest to first payment.

Next Issue: "Your First Carbon Deal - The Complete Implementation Guide"

Remember: In carbon markets, information asymmetry creates opportunity. Use it wisely.

Arbonics, "European Forest Carbon Credits 2025 Report," July 2025 https://agfundernews.com/competition-price-jumps-expected-as-demand-outpaces-supply-of-european-forest-carbon-credits

Carbon Herald, "Europe Faces Forest Carbon Credit Shortfall," July 2025 https://carbonherald.com/europe-faces-forest-carbon-credit-shortfall-amid-rising-demand-and-low-supply-arbonics-says/

AgFunder News, "Demand outpaces supply of European forest carbon credits," July 2025 https://agfundernews.com/competition-price-jumps-expected-as-demand-outpaces-supply-of-european-forest-carbon-credits

Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (EU) 2022/2464 https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20221107IPR49611/sustainable-economy-parliament-adopts-new-reporting-rules-for-multinationals

EUR-Lex, "Regulation (EU) 2024/3012 establishing a Union certification framework," December 2024 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/establishing-a-union-certification-framework-for-permanent-carbon-removals-carbon-farming-and-carbon-storage-in-products.html

Green Air News, "Airlines face major CORSIA offset costs from 2027," September 2025 https://www.greenairnews.com/?p=7938

Clean Energy Wire, "Germany's carbon pricing system," 2024 https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-planned-carbon-pricing-system-transport-and-buildings

Woodland Carbon Code, "UK Carbon Prices," Official Registry Data, 2024 https://www.woodlandcarboncode.org.uk/uk-carbon-prices

Carbon Credits.com, "Microsoft carbon credit purchase analysis," 2024 https://carboncredits.com/shell-and-microsoft-are-the-biggest-carbon-credit-buyers-in-2024-what-projects-do-they-support/

Allied Offsets, "Shell carbon credit strategy 2024" https://www.eenews.net/articles/shell-was-top-global-user-of-voluntary-carbon-credits-in-2024/

Natural England, "Biodiversity Credit Scheme Pilot," 2025 https://forestrycommission.blog.gov.uk/2024/08/02/selling-woodland-or-peatland-carbon-could-it-be-right-for-you/

European Commission, "EU Nature Credits Roadmap," July 2025 https://climate.ec.europa.eu/eu-action/carbon-removals-and-carbon-farming_en

Note: Some market dynamics are illustrated through composite examples. All statistical data is verified from cited sources. Projections are estimates based on current trends, not guarantees.

Cooperative improvement rates and technology cost savings represent indicative projections based on industry trends and documented pilot programs. Individual results may vary. Certification costs include consultant fees and total project expenses beyond basic registry fees.

Published by ForestryBrief Professional: Independent intelligence for forest economy stakeholders

Until Tuesday’s EFP!

Wish you all the best: Peter

P.S. What’s the biggest challenge you’re facing in forestry right now?
Hit reply and let me know — I read every message personally.

P.P.S: Want to share this info with someone? Send them the subscription link to ForestryBrief Professional.